Lost in Translation: Play Reviews

Posted on
Jan 27, 2010

A few months ago, we went to London so Rand could get some work done, and I could roam around the city and do fuck-all.

My life is good.

Our lovely friend Ben was with us, as he works with Rand, and their London colleagues needed him to reach things on the top shelf. No, wait. That wasn’t it. No. They needed Ben to provide the sort of unique and brilliant insight only he can offer. Besides that, he is very tall. Behold:

The title of this photo is Tiny Everywhereist, Tall Ben

The title of this photo is "Tiny Everywhereist, Tall Ben"

Okay, fine, so maybe, just maybe, I’m crouching in the above photo for dramatic effect. Ben isn’t quite that tall, but when you see the real photo of me standing next to him, it isn’t that dramatically different:

I like how hes looking down at me, somewhat bemused.

I like how he's looking down at me, somewhat bemused. "HOW'S THE WEATHER DOWN THERE? HA HA HA HA."

Notice how in both of those photos he’s kind of slouching. For some reason, I find Ben’s height totally fascinating, and fortunately he’s a very good sport about it. He has been for the 15+ years that we’ve known each other (and during that time, I don’t actually suspect he’s gotten any taller). I always make comments about what it must be like for Ben to fly coach or ride in the back seat of a car, and on this trip, I found out (Quote from Ben: “It’s pretty easy. I fold well.”). And I always wondered what it must be like for the people who have to sit behind him in a theater. And on this trip, I found that out too.

Though, to be honest, Ben basically fell asleep in his seat, so he was slouching quite a bit. Oh, and I’m pretty sure whoever was sitting behind him was asleep, too.

The moral of this story? Don’t ever believe theatrical reviews, especially if they are written by someone with different cultural references than you.

But I should probably start at the beginning. As I mentioned, we were in London, and while we had hoped for more free time to spend in the city, Ben and Rand ended up working quite a bit, leaving Ben with really only one night to hang out in London. And Rand and I came up with the otherwise great idea to see a play. The problem arose when Rand let me choose the play.

Having had a faint memory of once reading part of one of the plays being performed, and having seen about a half dozen glowing reviews for the same play, I picked it as the one we would see. The Times Online said “its tragicomic poise” made it “utterly compelling.” Another said it was “suprisingly watchable,” featuring “top-notch performances” from excellent actors. Still another said there was plenty of “gallows humor” on display, peppered with vaudevillian moments (am I wrong, or shouldn’t that suggest it’s somewhat funny?). No one gave it less than four stars. In short, they said, it was brilliant.

They’re all a bunch of liars.

Seriously, folks, heed my words: If you are an American, never, ever, listen to a play review about the comedic merits of something from a Briton. Because the results will be bad. You will try your best to be excited about it, but halfway through you’ll want to walk out (except there’s no damn intermission) and somewhere along the line you’ll realize that both your husband and your friend are asleep, as is 1/4 of the audience (confusing, because shouldn’t they, as Britons, have found it funny?) and you will want to hunt down the theatrical reviewer and strangle them with their own cravat (which you assume they wear all the time, along with a smoking jacket).

I suppose I should have known better. I suppose that taking two unsuspecting gentleman to see Endgame, arguably Beckett’s worse and most depressing play, was never going end well. But I believe in the power of reviews. If someone tells me something is fantastic, I will believe them, even if all my instincts and every single fiber of my body screams out to the contrary. I just assume that people don’t like crap, and that they won’t lead me astray. It’s why I rented and consequently watched nine painful minutes of a movie called “How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days.” It’s why I went to see “Daredevil” in the theater. (Note: not like you ever would, but don’t see either of those movies, ever. Instead, beat your head with a piece of wood while watching Fox News. It’s about as enjoyable.)

Some of you are probably thinking that this is American elitism at play, or that my palette isn’t sensitive enough to appreciate the tastes of English theater or some such crap. But I don’t think that’s the case. I love, and usually get, British humor. I think Eddie Izzard is a genius. I appreciate Monty Python, despite the fact that I’m not a 16-year-old boy wearing a fedora and a Hawaiian shirt. I get these things.

Instead, what I’m saying is, the British are too polite to give sincere reviews. This was the case we had when asking people about good restaurants in London. Everything was “quite nice.” And the same was true of theater reviews: everything was brilliant. And even as I looked at the audience, dropping like flies into unconsciousness, I wondered how many of them would leave the theater and tell their friends, “Yeah, it was brilliant.” Quite a few, I suspect.

As for me, I feel indebted to Rand and Ben for sitting through an hour and a half of excruciating “brilliance”. I promise to make it up to them. But this time, we’re going to see something here in the states. After all, we might not be perfect, but when we review something, we mean it.

Leave a Comment

  • No, Brits can give sincere reviews. Try Matthew Norman, The Guardian’s restaurant reviwer – more than once I’ve seen him give scores of 1 or 0. Here’s a recent example. http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/series/matthewnorman. Whilst this review of The Hulk is one of the finest reviews, of any kind, I’ve ever read: http://www.guardian.co.uk/film/2008/jun/13/actionandadventure.sciencefictionandfantasy.

    It’s just that nearly all theatre reviewers, in any country I’ve been to, think Beckett is ace. He’s not. He’s shite.

    • Geraldine

      Holy cow – Hulk review Brilliant. Make Everywhereist laugh. Not smash.

  • Aren’t all of Beckett’s plays his most depressing? Did you at least get ice cream? We saw a lot of shows when we were in London, but our favorite part was that you could eat ice cream in the theater.

  • I don’t think this is a uniquely British thing. I find that I generally hate anything “critically acclaimed” and love the stuff they pan. I think if you watch too many plays or see too many movies (as critics must do in order to do their job) you lose touch with what normal people think is amusing and only see clever oblique references to other things you’ve seen.

    Or maybe that’s just me.

  • I hope you were left with enough time to look at that big clock.

  • If your’re coming over for SES (might be there myself, not made my mind up yet) then you ‘might’ enjoy this sculpture ‘http://www.livincool.com/art/anish-kapoor-at-the-royal-accademy-of-arts-london’ – won’t make you laugh, but it is intriguing

    • Geraldine

      Elaine – we will totally be there, and excited to see the silver Rum baba tower statue.

  • Suz

    He does fold well. 😀

  • I went to see a play that turned out to be in spanish. Which neither me or the friend I dragged along speak. Fortunately, there was an intermission but it didn’t come until an hour and a half in. It’s so much worse if you’re the one that’s responsible for the pain.

    • Geraldine

      Lucy – oh, too true – while at least the play was in English (woefully, long, drawn-out English), I nevertheless felt a huge degree of guilt, knowing it was my fault. Which is funny, because if the situation was reversed, I wouldn’t have blamed Rand or Ben (and it’s not that they blamed me – rather, I blamed myself). Ah, well – we have an over-developed empathy gene, you and I. 🙂

  • YES!! This is so unbelievably true. Do you know how bad the reviews were last spring for The Book of Mormon on the West End? Yes, for the freaking Book of Mormon, one of the greatest and definitely the funniest Broadway musical ever. I actually thought it was more well done than the original production. Stupid London critics!

More from The Blog

On Instagram @theeverywhereist

  • My Chrissy has had this on her fridge for a decade. Rand was exhausted, and we were six months away from getting married.
  • Did I buy this ridiculous 80s era overcoat from the Goodwill? Yes. Has Rand expressed profound skepticism over it? Yes.
  • He stole my apron, but he made me risotto.
  • Rand just gave me this pin for Valentine's Day and told me he's the Ralph Wiggum of our relationship. #choochoochooseyou #jonwye #valentinesday
  • An absolutely gorgeous venue for @andreadunlop's book launch. SHE REGRETS NOTHING is out today, and is a suspenseful, salacious, scintillating read. So proud of you, Andrea.
  • Doctor said my cold has ravaged my lungs. This is one instance where I could have gone without the metaphors.
  • How does my brother know how to say the exactly wrong thing to cheer me up? 😂
  • Sick day. Working on an op-ed that I can't turn in until tomorrow because I'm too busy watching This Is Us and feeling terrible. (BTW, I am *such* a Toby.)
  • The most handsome man in the world bought me a taco and sang me Billy Bragg. We talked about regret, and he told me he was sorry he took up so much of my life. And I laughed. Because it's not his fault that I can't stop thinking about him.
  • It's the 25th anniversary of Andre the Giant's passing. Here's the time I dressed up as him for Halloween.

All Over The Place

Buy my book and I promise I'll never ask you for anything again.